![]() |
![]() |
|||
|
Reading 9-12 Research Reviews |
||||
| About This Project Selecting Content Definitions Upcoming Additions How to Get Studies Help | ||||
|
|
||||
|
Summary Tables The following links take you to summary tables for particular topics of interest. Bold topics, from Comprehension to Meta-analyses, have tables farther down this page. Comprehension has the added feature of separate subtopic pages, such as Skills Instruction. Each subtopic link (both in this list and in the 4th column) opens a separate page.
|
Comprehension (Top of page • Finding & Printing Suggestions)
|
Study Name |
Design Rating |
Strategy, Subjects,
Effects |
Topics | ||||||||||||||
|
Table
information is abbreviated. Click "Read full review" links below for full
citations of author and journal names and for details about the
studies. | |||||||||||||||||
|
Study: Effects of interactive discussion and text type on learning counterintuitive science concepts. reading_9-12_17 |
5 |
Strategy: Determine usefulness of interactive discussion to
help modify intuitive understandings of complex science concepts. Students
randomly assigned to 1 of 6 conditions in a 3 x 2 factorial design.
Treatment conditions: discussion web, question/answer worksheet and a
control. Each student participated in large-group and small-group session.
Two conditions required students to discuss in pairs. Discussion webs used
to structure interactive discussions Subjects: 86 9th graders in rural Georgia; 40% European American, 60% African-American Results: No significance reported |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Reading for meaning: The efficacy of reciprocal teaching in fostering reading comprehension in high school students in remedial reading classes. reading_9-12_33 |
5 |
Strategy: Reciprocal teaching Subjects: 75 Chapter I remedial reading freshmen from 2 suburban high schools. They were mainstreamed into regular education with average intelligence. There were considered poor comprehenders but adequate decoders. Results: The significant improvement in reading comprehension skills in the experimental group demonstrates the effectiveness of using reciprocal teaching strategies with remedial high school students. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Teaching students to generate questions: A review of the intervention studies. reading_4-6_32 |
4 |
Strategy: Generation of Questions Subjects: The grade levels of the students in these studies ranged from third grade through college. Results: Overall, teaching students to generate questions on the text they have read resulted in gains in comprehension, as measure by tests given at the end of the intervention. Effect size was +.36 when standardized tests were used, and +.86 when experimenter-developed comprehension tests were used. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 3-5, 6-8, 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Reading instruction that increases thinking abilities. reading_4-6_38 |
4 |
Strategy: Thinking Abilities. Subjects: 168 sixth and seventh graders with average grade point of 2.36 on a 4-point scale in four large metropolitan schools in the southwest Results: Effect Size for Reading Total on ITBS= +1.11 |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 6, 8, 9 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The potential for directing study in combined reading and writing activity. reading_7-8_42 |
4 |
Strategy:
Paraphrasing, Questioning, Comparing/Contrasting after reading
|
Reading
Topics: Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Are good texts always better? Interactions of text coherence, background knowledge, and levels of understanding in learning from text. reading_7-8_52 |
4 |
Strategy: Construction/Integration Models of Text
Comprehension |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 7, 8, 9 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Group discussions and large-scale language arts assessments: Effects on students' comprehension. reading_9-12_18 |
4 |
Strategy: Peer collaboration (group discussion)
during language arts assessment |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Active comprehension: Problem-solving schema with question generation for comprehension of complex short stories. reading_9-12_43 |
4 |
Strategy: Problem Solving/Question
Generation Subjects: Students from 3 11th-grade English classes Results: High school students can learn to apply a problem-solving schema, combining schema-general questions to fit complex stories and a strategy of generating story-specific questions. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The compensatory effect of graphic organizers on descriptive text. reading_9-12_48 |
4 |
Strategy: Graphic Organizers effect on descriptive
text Subjects: 114 tenth graders in Regents and non-Regents courses at a small city high school in upstate New York. Results: Both skilled and unskilled readers benefited from the instruction using organizers in this study. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Direct instruction of summarization skills. reading_9-12_63 |
4 |
Strategy:
Direct instruction of summarization skills |
Reading
Topics: Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Effects of peer- assisted learning strategies on high school students with serious reading problems. reading_9-12_117 |
Added
8-10-05 3 |
Strategy:
Peer-Assisted Learning Strategies (PALS)
|
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Diverse Learners Keywords: PALS, comprehension, fluency, diverse learners | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Examining the reading difficulty of secondary students with learning disabilities - Expository versus narrative text. reading_9-12_149 |
3 |
Strategy:
Expository vs. Narrative Text Impact on Comprehension
|
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The effect of strategic notetaking on the recall and comprehension of lecture information for high school students with learning disabilities. reading_9-12_150 |
3 |
Strategy:
Strategic Note Taking |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Diverse Learners Keywords: notetaking, learning disabled, comprehension | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The effects of instruction in a paired associates strategy on the information mastery performance of students with learning disabilities. reading_9-12_151 |
3 |
Strategy:
Paired Associates Strategy |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: learning disabilities, mnemonics, recall | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Monitoring and resolving comprehension obstacles: An investigation of spontaneous text lookbacks among upper-grade good and poor comprehenders. reading_4-6_23 |
2 |
Strategy: Rereading the text or "looking back" in
order to respond to improve comprehension Subjects: 19 fourth thru tenth graders who were considered "poor-comprehenders" (pc) attending a summer reading clinic who could decode and 19 "good comprehenders" (gc) in grades six thru eight chosen the following school year who matched the pc group Results: Poor comprehenders mostly failed to demonstrate monitoring and mostly failed to spontaneously use look backs. The study implies that readers' knowing they did not know (an answer to the question) preceded knowing what to do to resolve the dilemma (self-monitoring before solution). |
Reading
Topics: Grades: 3-5, 6-8, 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Middle and high school students' perceptions of how they experience text-based discussions: A multicase study reading_7-8_6 |
2 |
Strategy:
Researchers looked at individual roles students play in a
classroom discussion and how they perceive roles. Three rounds of
classroom discussions were videotaped followed by three focal group
interviews. Reserachers developed a procedure for recording,
triangulating, analyzing and sharing observations. |
Reading
Topics: Grades: 3-5, 6-8, 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: What happens when students read multiple source documents in history? reading_9-12_11 |
2 |
Strategy: Students read documents on controversial incident
in U.S. history; asked to describe or to develop opinion. Read text;
selected options for more info (primary & tertiary sources, pro and
anti the topic) & for vocab explanation; recalled without looking
back; did relationship task; answered questionnaire. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Teaching high school students to identify main ideas in expository text. reading_9-12_16 |
2 |
Strategy: Identification of main ideas in expository
text
|
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The development and evaluation of a self-questioning study technique. reading_9-12_60 |
2 |
Strategy:
Self-questioning Subjects: First study - 29 seniors; second study 81 juniors and seniors average or above average and randomly assigned to one of the three experimental groups. Results: The self-questioning with training showed a significant main effect for treatment. Both studies indicated that student generation of questions during study is more effective for lower verbal students than for higher verbal ability students. |
Reading Topics:
Comprehension Questioning Strategies Strategy Instruction Text Structure Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
2 |
Strategy:
Note taking skills |
||||||||||||||||
|
Study: How automatically do readers infer fictional characters emotional states? reading_9-12_152 |
2 |
Strategy: Automatic inferences using divided
attention tasks |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12, college Keywords:
comprehension, inferencing, characters
| ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Activating the inactive learner: Advance organizers in the secondary content classroom. reading_ku_178 |
Added
8-10-05 2 |
Strategy:
Advance organizers |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Diverse Learners Keywords: student retention, advance organizers | ||||||||||||||
Study: Effectiveness of a concept teaching routine in enhancing the performance of LD students in secondary-level mainstream classes. reading_ku_179 |
Added 3-11-06 2 |
Strategy: Concept Diagrams and Concept Teaching Routine Results: Effect Size - |
Reading Topics: Grades: 9-12 Keywords: advanced organizers, concepts |
||||||||||||||
|
Study: The Strategies Intervention Model: A model for supported inclusion at the secondary level. reading_ku_175 |
Added
9-1-05 1.5 |
Strategy:
Intervention model for inclusion at the secondary level (SIM)
|
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Diverse Learners Keywords: Teaching interventions | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Is October Brown Chinese? A cultural modeling activity system for underachieving students. reading_4-6_51 |
1 |
Strategy: Cultural Modeling Project Subjects: Intact class taught by the researcher at an all-African American high school; 69% were from low-income families. Results: Despite low scores on standardized reading tests, under-achieving students are capable of higher order thinking and application of this skill to literature. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 9-12 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Project CRISS: Reading, writing and studying strategies for literature and content. reading_4-6_106 |
1 |
Strategy: CRISS Subjects: CRISS developmental site (Kalispell, MT.) and two replication sites. Grades 4, 6, 8, and 11. Note: no description of participant or demographics. Results: Significant gains were made by each of the Project CRISS groups at each site. Students in CRISS groups were able to recall twice as much information as students in the control group. Students' posttesting paragraphs explaining what they did to read and learn differed. Experimental students used a rich assortment and often used multiple strategies. |
Reading Topics: Grades: 4, 6, 8, 11 Keywords: recall, reading strategies, organization, memory, vocabulary, writing strategies |
||||||||||||||
|
Study: Activating background knowledge in reading comprehension assessment. reading_4-6_10 |
Meta-analysis |
Strategy: Schema elaboration in response to purpose
questions Subjects: 24 first graders, 28 sixth graders from intact elementary classes, and 22 tenth graders selected by high school administrators as a cross-section of the academic abilities from 2 schools in a small-city school district in south-central Indiana. Most were from white, middle-income families. Results: Students at all grade levels were able to use purpose questions to activate background knowledge and make prediction about passage content. Content information activated was dependent upon student familiarity with the topic or on the number of familiar concepts also presented in the purpose question. Schema elaboration in the responses appeared to vary by purpose question. First graders tended to tell stories when asked to predict passage content. Sixth and tenth grade responses were found to be dependent upon the purpose question asked. |
Reading Topics: Grades: 1, 6, 10 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: The interaction of domain-specific and strategic knowledge in academic performance. reading_7-8_62 |
Literature Review |
Strategy:
Domain-specific and strategic knowledge in academic
performance |
Reading Topics: Grades: 7+ Keywords: background knowledge, schema, metacognition | ||||||||||||||
|
Study: Thinking aloud and reading comprehension research: Inquiry, instruction, and social interaction. reading_meta_35 |
Literature |
Summary: [The study] suggests that thinking aloud has been an important pradigm for research in reading comprehension and reading comprehension instruction. It also suggests that thinking aloud will continue to play an important role in future research directed toward investigating social constructivist models for reading comprehension instruction. |
Reading Topics:
Grades: 3-5, 6-8 Keywords: | ||||||||||||||
Fluency
No studies currently listed
Phonemic Awareness
No studies currently listed
Phonics
No studies currently listed
Vocabulary (Top of page • Finding & Printing Suggestions)
|
Study Name |
Design Rating |
Strategy, Subjects,
Effects |
Topics |
|
Table
information is abbreviated. Click "Read full review" links below for full
citations of author and journal names and for details about the
studies. | |||
|
Study: The use and effectiveness of analogical instruction in diverse secondary content classrooms. reading_9-12_147 |
3-4 |
Strategy: Analogical Instruction: Concept
Anchoring Table and Routine |
Reading Topics: Diverse Learners Grades: 9-12 Keywords: |
|
Study: Context clues are unreliable predictors of word meanings. reading_9-12_2 |
3 |
Strategy: Context Clues Subjects: Exp 153 10th graders and 48 11th graders in a Florida private school middle/upper-middle class Exp 239 11th graders in a Florida private school middle/upper-middle class Exp 384 10th and 11th graders in private Hebrew Day School in Florida Results: None of the experiments showed a statistically significant effect due to the context. |
Reading Topics: Grades: 10, 11 Keywords: |
|
Study: Effects of computer-assisted vocabulary training on word knowledge reading_9-12_14 |
2 |
Strategy: Word Attack! Software program Subjects: (171) 11th graders in rural central Pennsylvania Results: The results of the study demonstrated that students who used a modified mixed approach, that is, one that provides sentence context, definitional or synonym clues, and optional word choices, learned more words than did students who received definitional information only. |
Reading Topics:
Vocabulary |
|
Study: The effects of vocabulary instruction: A model-based meta-analysis. reading_4-6_54 |
Meta-analysis 4 |
Strategy: Vocabulary Instruction Subjects: NA Results: Vocabulary instruction does appear to have a significant effect on the comprehension of passages containing taught words (effect sizes averaged +.97*) and passages not necessarily containing taught words (effect size +.30) |
Reading Topics:
Keywords: |
|
Study: Teaching children to learn word meanings from context: A synthesis and some questions. reading_meta_19 |
Meta- |
Summary: What do fourteen studies show about approaches aimed at teaching children to be more efficient at learning words from context? Does teaching the use of context clues make sensible use of limited time available for reading instruction? |
Reading Topics:
Keywords: |
Note: The Iowa Department of Education does not recommend the adoption of any program, strategy, practice or routine reviewed on this site. Information on this site should be viewed as information for use by districts and staff development providers as they plan staff development programs aimed at increasing the achievement of all their students.
Path: State of Iowa > Educate > PK-12 Education > Educator Quality > Professional Development > Iowa Professional Development for Student Achievement > Content Network > Reading 9-12
Updated 11-7-2006
______________________
* When effect sizes are averaged the results are more prone to error.